Friday, February 06, 2009

Who the FISH is Dr Stephen Carr Leon?

DISCLAIMER (15 August 2010):

ANOTHER ANONYMOUS COMMENT LIKE ANONYMOUS AUGUST 14, 2010, AND I'M TAKING THIS ARTICLE DOWN BECAUSE APPARENTLY ANONYMOUS ARE PURE IDIOTS WHO CANNOT DIFFERENTIATE SIMPLE THINGS ABOUT LIFESTYLE. LIKE WHY ARE YOU SO STUPID TO EVEN REALIZE MY ARTICLE CLEARLY SAYS THAT THE THINGS SO CALLED BEING 'RESEARCHED' ARE BASIC FUNDAMENTALS ON HOW TO LIVE A HEALTHY LIFESTYLE??

AND WHAT IS IT ABOUT "menyokong yahudi yang terang2 musuh islam" AND ALL?? Why the hell am I being attacked on supporting the Jews?? If someone has taken MY ARTICLE to claim it is PURE HOAX and then supported the Jews, I am at fault?? An ABSOLUTELY ORDINARY BLOGGER LIKE ME? Not a celebrity, not a politician, etc?? Ayeay, you kidding me?

Your comment on "ambil perkara yang baik dan iktibar", okay please do the same to this article I wrote eh?


I LEAVE THIS SPACE FOR THE GOOD OF YOU PEOPLE TO COMMENT, SO PLEASE HAVE SOME RESPECT ON MY, I REPEAT, MY, PLAYGROUND.
If you disagree with me, LEAVE THIS BLOG or if you NEED to comment, learn some respect in your comments. I did not bash any of you for believing Leon's article, so shouldn't you.


After all, this is a PERSONAL BLOG, not your daily informative blog.

Sheesh. *rolls eyes*




I have to be honest with you that I can be pretty addicted to research. That is why whenever my friends send me interesting articles in the mail, I tend to search online and read more about it.

Earlier today, I received an e-mail with the subject "Something About Yahudi" from Cik Bit. I thought it'd be interesting to read, so I downloaded the word document.

Indeed, it was interesting. someone claimed that while browsing through some websites, he stumbled upon a thesis by Dr Stephen Carr Leon entitled "Why the Jews so smart". And this man, took the effort (more like trouble) to translate part of the thesis to the Malay Language.

I'm not gonna post the lengthy article here, but these are some excerpts of the article. For full article, just google, trust me, you can NEVER FAIL to find the so-called malay translated article.

Ketika tahun kedua, akhir bulan December 1980 dan sedang saya menghitung hari untuk pulang ke California saya terfikir apakah sebab nya kaum Yahudi begitu pintar? Kenapa tuhan memberi kelebihan kepada mereka? Apakah ini suatu kebetulan? Atau olah manusia sendiri? Adakah bijak boleh dijana? Seperti kilang pengeluaran?

Maka saya pon tergerak membuat tesis untuk Phd saya, disamping kebaikan untuk umat sejagat dan dapat hidup secara harmoni. Untuk pengetahuan anda tesis yang saya lakukan ini mengambil masa hampir lapan tahun, ini kerana untuk mengumpulkan data-data yang setepat mungkin.

Di Israel, setelah mengetahui yang sang ibu sedang mengandung, pertama kali saya perhatikan ialah, sang ibu akan sering menyanyi dan bermain piano dan si ibu dan bapa akan membeli buku metamatik dan menyelesaikan masalah metamatik bersama suami, saya sungguh hairan kerana teman saya yang mengandung sering membawa buku metamatik dan bertanya kepada saya beberapa soalan yang beliau tak dapat menyelesaikanya, oleh kerana saya memang minat tentang metamatik, tentu saja dengan senang saya bantu beliau. Saya bertanya kepada beliau, adakah ini untuk anak kamu? Beliau menjawab, “ia, ini untuk anak saya yang masih didalam kandungan, saya sedang melatih otak beliau, semuga ia menjadi genius apabila dewasa kelak”

Seperkara lagi yang saya perhatikan ialah pemakanan beliau, sejak awal mengandung beliau gemar sekali memakan kacang badam dan korma bersama susu , dan untuk tengah hari makan utama beliau ialah roti dan ikan tanpa kepala bersama salad yang digaul dengan badam dan berbagai jenis kekacang, menurut beliau daging ikan sungguh baik untuk perkembangan otak dan kepala ikan mengandungi kimia yang tidak baik yang dapat merosakkan pengembangan dan penumbuhan otak anak didalam kandungan.

Di Israel, merokok adalah taboo, apabila anda diundang makan dirumah Yahudi, jangan sekali kali merokok, dan tanpa malu mereka akan menyuruh anda keluar dari rumah mereka dam merokok diluar rumah mereka.

Perhatian saya selanjutnya ialah melawati tadika mereka, Pemakanan anak anak tadi cukup dikawal, makanan awal ialah buah buahan bersama kacang badam, diikuti dengan menelan pil minyak ikan (code oil lever) Didalam pengamatan saya, kanak Yahudi sungguh bijak dan rata rata mereka memahami 3 bahasa iaitu Hebrew, Arab dan Inggeris dan sedari awal lagi mereka telah dilatih bermain piano dan violin, ini adalah suatu kewajipan. Menurut mereka bermain musik dan memahami nota notanya dapat meningkatkan lagi IQ kanak kanak dan sudah tentu bakal menjadikan budak itu bijak.

Kesimpulanya, pada teori saya, melahirkan anak dan keturunan yg bijak boleh dilaksanakan dan tentunya bukan semalaman, ianya memerlukan masa, beberapa jenerasi mungkin? Persiapan awal adalah ketika sang ibu mengandung, galakkanlah siibu melakukan latihan metamatik yg mudah tetapi konsisten disamping mendengar musik klasik. Seterusnya ubahlah cara pemakanan, makanlah makanan yg elok dan berhasiat yg baik untuk otak, menghayati musik sejak kecil adalah baik sekali untuk penumbuhan otak kanak kanak, dengan bermain piano dan violin sudah tentu dapat melatih anak anak mencerdaskan otak mereka demikian juga sukan yg memerlukan konsetrasi yg tinggi, seperti memanah, bola keranjang, dart dan menembak.

Selamat sejahtera dan semuga kita dapat melahirkan manusia yg bijak dan bersifat mulia untuk kebaikan manusia sejagat tanpa mengenal batasan bangsa.

Dr. Stephen Carr Leon

After reading the article, I google-d for Dr Stephen Carr Leon. I was hoping that I could get the English version as the sender of this article claimed he found Dr Leon's article on the web. But, I wasn't surprised when I COULD NOT FIND any English version of this thesis. Do this, and you'll only get a list of all the Malay translated article.

And for this, I may conclude that:
  • Dr Stephen Carr Leon DOESN'T EXIST. Neither does his thesis.
  • An Average Joe wrote this article but he had to claim that it is a thesis so that the article looks like it is proven BY RESEARCH.
  • The moment I read the thesis is entitled "Why the Jews so smart", I knew this is a hoax. The sentence may have semantics, but not the grammar. What happened to "Why the Jews ARE so smart"?? Someone ate the ARE in the process of translation?
  • He wrote this for his PhD?? What the fish. I've never seen a thesis this simple for a PhD level.
I do agree that who-ever wrote this article made some really good points about why those people are clever (let's not generalize ALL Jews). But these are just some healthy lifestyle that are known too many. The only difference is, some practices it, some don't.

To the Average Joe who wrote this article, you've made your point. And yes, people are believing this article by spamming another persons inbox. Oops, sorry Biha! Hehe.

Anyway, if Dr Stephen Carr Leon is REAL and his thesis can be found somewhere, please buzz me. I may have to delete this post then. Haha. But don't attempt to fool me.


80 other story teller(s):

cik bit said...

lain kali
x nk pos apa2 kt ko
spamming..
u hurt me..ouchh
huhuhuhuh

atreyu strange said...

ouhh. spam lah lagi! baru lah ada mende nak tulis kat blog! ngeeee~

Anonymous said...

hi, indeed i did the same thing as u, i Google up this chap's name hoping to find his original article in English & i ended up reading ur blog instead!;D

atreyu strange said...

lol, so you have not found his 'English version' too eh? someone better find his thesis soon.. i can't wait! *rolling eyes* hehe.

e | | i n said...

Ya. I received it today via email as well. It doesn't look like a thesis to me. The 'kesahihan' is very much doubtful indeed. Bwahaha~~

aina rahim said...

as I found the article interesting, I googled this name also, but found nothing that I cud believe..haha

atreyu strange said...

aina, the article does look interesting. but like what ellin said, kesahihannya diragui. hehe~

Anonymous said...

huhu... i also got connected to this blog...
yet the statements are TRUE based on my study(i am a pharmacy student)..
FISH, NUTS, FRUITS and MUSIC plus MATH...
For pregnant mother if cant follow everything half should be ok...

atreyu strange said...

and that is why i said some 'average joe' needed the kick to pass this article to everyone, so he used some Dr's name (which, I STILL DOUBT exist. huhu).

Anonymous said...

Yeah...i tried to googled also but found ur blog instead.
Hoax or not, I believe the writer has good intention...

Anonymous said...

Haa..haa.. thanks for pointing out that there is no such person as Dr-whatever-his-name. Rasanye, org Melayu ni tera invent benda2 mengarut nih .. so, sapa kat Jews lagi tera dari Melayu? Hee..hee..

atreyu strange said...

Hehe. Betol tu anonymous sekalian (len kali kasik name la wei!)! They have delivered good points in the article. I wonder why the writer don't just use his/her own name.

Anonymous said...

but actually this man really exist, you guys can check http://www.vitals.com/doctor/profile/1629021811

Anonymous said...

Hi ...

Or How about this
http://www.english.pitt.edu/people/faculty/carr-stephen.html

The problem is the "L", are sure Is it "Leon"?
BLUR!

And Is the article really his thesis?

atreyu strange said...

Well in both cases, you pointed out someone who has 'Carr' as his last name. Unfortunately, in the article, 'Carr' is suppose to be his middle name, whereas 'Leon' is his last name. If 'Leon' is his last name, then it should have been Stephen C. Leon, not Stephen L. Carr. So, I think that's not him. Huhu. Any one else who doesn't agree?

Anonymous said...

yang sedihnya.. article yang takde hujung pangkal ni lah yang jadi topik utama tazkirah sebelum solat jumaat di masjid as-syakirin klcc 2 minggu lepas, no doubt there's good content, but its unethical thing to do if you ask me, taking from unreliable source and spread it to public.

atreyu strange said...

ouhh, really? wow, tak sangka kan. dh lah kat masjid center of the city. mesti ramai yg pegi dgr.

yes, i agree that it is unethical. and coming from people who are religious, the public will be bound to believe him, rite?

i hope mereka2 yg dh pegi tu akan search blk and stumble upon this blog. let me tell you again, NOT TO BELIEVE THE WRITER OF THE ARTICLE PLEASE. it is COMMON points that we all know abt.

neobita said...

thanks for the info,
you really like to search online for your information right? good, so do I.
But if you may, I would like to suggest you to earn money while you search... (I earn average 0.20 Pence per day... hehehe I know its not much... but its better than nothing right? if you search more, most likely you will earn more... contact me through my website for more information k...

My Homepage Friends


sorry for the advertisements, but really thank you for the information...

Anonymous said...

Org Yahudi ni Allah dah anugerahkan pada depa cerdas otaknya, dan mati jiwanya. Artikel menggalakkan anak2 dalam perut mendengar klasikal musik, walhal kita ni digalakkan untuk memperdengarkan bacaan Quran pada bayi dalam perut. Sudah seharusnya artikel sebegini licik di perhalusi sumbernya sebelum diterima bulat2 sebagai satu artikel sahih

Anonymous said...

hi.. i am the first anonymous after ur last comment to cik bit & my name's sunny... anyway what fascinates me is that why in the world would a malay or perhaps a malay speaking someone who actually took the trouble to come up with the article in malay(of which we have established that we could not find the original article in English). FYI i even went to google up for articles regarding food & pregnancy in jewish culture..but so far have found nothing to establish the above article...

atreyu strange said...

perhaps someone wants to see if he could influence others with this article. and unfortunately, half of those who read it, seems to believe it.

it truly shows that a gossip can be as close as the truth when one starts believing in it and passing it on to others.

*gosh, there's sooOo many anonymous in here, i lost count! huhu~

hubahuba said...

aisey.. im also caught in this haox... and end up reading ur blog also.. hahaha

A.A said...

Me also! I like your heading :D What the fish! haha

To the 2 anonymous who posted the links of the 'Dr Stephen L Carr', try reading their profile:

- The doctor is a radiologist practicing in Florida & never did a PhD, let alone in Israel
- The 2nd one is NOT a doctor - he's an associate professor in English

So no, they are not the so-called 'Dr Stephen L Carr' as claimed in the spam email. In fact, I bet he doesn't exist.

It's mind boggling just how easy the majority of Malays would take everything, hook, line & sinker, simply because: 1) It has Yahudi in it (and we know how anti-semitic Malays are) and 2) It appears to be credible when indeed none of them did their research.

The message sure is good, basically it's common sense no? (ie not smoking, taking fish oil rich in omega 3 & 6, etc) Healthy eating & lifestyle is good, but its nothing new.

Conning people into thinking it's credible is as the others have said, is unethical. But oh well, mcm tu lah a lot of the Malays in Malaysia - ikut je ape org ckp, blindly forwarding without researching, sgt xcritical or analytical.

Generalizing, maybe (I'm Malay myself) but just a bit sick of all this 'Fikir-fikirkan lah' & anti-semitic crap flooding my mail. I have some nice Yahudi friends from France, Switzerland and its frustrating how idiots like the author are fueling the antisemiticism even more.

Nur_Hijrah said...

Noted, thank for the info :)

-sandmaster- said...

Yes, I also think that it is safe to say that this article is a hoax.
There are some good points but doesn't mean that the Jews are geniuses.
Not supporting the Jews but I pity of the Muslims especially Malays that are so gullible to believe this without doing their research.
there's a lot of articles similar to this that has been circulating through emails and such.
Thanks for the info too.

atreyu strange said...

hubahuba, i bet you'd be laughing by now thinking that you ALMOST believed it! me too actually, hehe!

A.A., wow, calm down. huhu~

Nur Hijrah and Sandmaster, glad that you stumbled upon this blog! Now, go spread the news it's a HOAX! Go, GO! heh~

Anonymous said...

Yep... indeed i did the same thing. .in English & i ended up reading ur blog instead!

Anonymous said...

haha,
same thing happened to me, ended up reading ur blog jer...and i just forwarded the email to others too...

atreyu strange said...

dem! you shouldn't have! uhuh.

but on a brighter note, maybe they will start searching and stumble upon my blog eh?? hehe~

hani said...

jom baca michael crichton:)

Anonymous said...

haha, who the fish is atreyu also? can't see much on your profile la.. jgn malu2

- b o g -

atreyu strange said...

hani, aku kene baca byk lg jurnal ILMIAH kat ofiz tu! huhu. cian aku!

b o g, kau pun tak kurang malunyer. apsal anonymous jek. haha~

konpius said...

https://bookweb.kinokuniya.co.jp/ez/bsea.cgi?ISBN=1559581506

mungkin dari sini.. nama btol mungkin Steven Carr Reuben
tajuk buku " Raising Jewish Children in a Contemporary World : The Modern Parent's Guide to Creating a Jewish Home -US-"

http://www.rebreuben.com/

nak tgk muka nya.. rabbi rupanya mcm paderi la dlam jew

tp nama lain la lam emel tu stephen carr leon tp yg nih steven carr-reuben

tp bidangnya sama la pasai pendidikan budak2

byk tapinya.. dah pening mana yg btol nihhhhh

kalau cari kat google scholar kluar juga

atreyu strange said...

konpius, first of all, it should be a THESIS, not a book.

second, the supposed thesis author is NOT A JEW. this one that you try to prove us is a JEW unfortunately.

thirdly, NAME. yes, kalu dah salah MEMANG salah. mana mungkin the so-called translator hebat giler gi translate tp boleh pulak tersilap name??

sori beb, hujah tak diterima. haha. aku dah lame dalam bidang research ni, so aku sangat cerewet bila nak sahihkan sesuatu. hehe.

imrnze said...

this is a great 'debate' (if i may say so).

i myself keen to believe this was a hoax too, tapi yang jelasnya (?) with good intention.

cuma, my pov (about the research utk sahihkan); maybe the name has been altered or 'distorted' somehow in the process of 'spamming'. Thats the nature of information communication, bila dah terlalu banyak transmission nodes, the integrity of information degraded or totally changed.

It might started as D. Stephen Lars Ian (or whatever) but end up instead as Dr. Stephen Carr Leon. Just like "Why jews [are] so smart" perhaps some average jane terdelete somehow or watnot.

So my safe bet is that, we start researching by looking at the exact words & letters and expand later to other possibilities.. which cud be zillions.. eh?

Anyhow, there's a good point in that 'hoax'. Just the integrity of "the story" is doubtful. So to me, take what is good (can proof this someplace else) and buang yang keruh;)

But a shame it became a topic khutbah, simply like that (if being khutbah letter to letter -that is).

I'm ending my part of this research, going about something else more beneficial than this.. :)

salam y'all.

p/s: good to know there are still critical thinking ppl 'among us'.

p/p/s: pardon my english.

-mrn

atreyu strange said...

excuse me, but who do you mean by 'among us'? malays? if that's what you're implying, im sorry to say that i am not a malay. and yes, it seems you're implying malays in that context - which is not cool at all.

be a MALAYSIAN, ppl. i beg you.

Anonymous said...

someone even bothered to insert anti-Indonesian slant into the so-called translation. Gosh, when will people realize that not all of what you read in the mail is true?

tinie said...

gud article dear..

this is malaysian. Susahnya nk ubah sikap yg asik nak fwd without tau btul2 mana sumbernya.. Huh..

Anonymous said...

tesis phd mana boleh publish suka-suka je online. memangla kalau search kat google takkan jumpa. Korang tryla search kat online journal cam scopus ke, science direct ke, mungkin boleh jumpa. Ni lah satu lagi perangai orang kita, belum pape lagi dah buat kesimpulan. Si owner bedtimestorie ni pun satu, kalau betul wat research, watla betul2. Ni cepat sangat wat conclusion. Apa barang.
Jangan mare aa...sekadar pandangan.

atreyu strange said...

The anonymous above me, I don't SIMPLY jump to conclusion. Just so you know, I am working as a Research Scientist, so like I said, don't attempt to fool me. And I'm not stupid about all this research.

Anonymous said...

That's not a thesis. That's an article about a thesis posted in some Indonesian Jihad-oriented magazine. Even if the thesis did not exist, I think that if the article helps people to stop smoking, I'm inclined to supporting it.

Anonymous said...

hai guys, i just read the article about this, my friend sent it to me. i did try to google about dr stephen carr leon and end up reading this blog...just like u guys, i do doubt about it...however the health tips in the article are true!

lutfi said...

ditto guys. anything new keep me posted. lets track down this leon bugger. or whoever the fish the author is.

lutfi said...

you peeps might wanna try "steven carr leon," with a "V"

atreyu strange said...

lutfi, have you tried that yourself? come back to us with the results when you find something useful. ahaa~

Anonymous said...

i got this from my email.. OMG is that true HOAX?

Nisa said...

I read this article on facebook......

and I've also googled it, and cant find anything -____-

and I found your blog.

more irritatingly, on "my friend's facebook notes" version, the article mentioned Indonesia as an example of Smoking country.

But whats the point of this kinda hoax?

good writings anyway, great point of view.

atreyu strange said...

Nisa, yes in fact, in the version that I have, they mentioned Indonesian. If you search further, you will find many Indonesian bloggers who are annoyed with this article. Huhu.

Anyway, I'm still looking for Dr Leon. So, if he's hiding somewhere, lemme know. Ahaa~

neilhoja said...

owh.. ternyata... xixixiix

wb said...

"hi. i come from california, perlis. i have a phd in rumour-identification, therefore everyone must believe me. my thesis is only written in one sentence (that shows how great i am) and apparently, the only language my thesis has ever been translated into is bahasa melayu."

ok ok ignore the above. i'm a malaysian, ethnically malay, and i don't like forwarded emails or comments that try to generalize or stereotype a race, even if it means something good or bad about that race.. oh well.. people can be so gullible....

atreyu strange said...

Haha. Wb, what a great sense of humor you have!

Anyway, am STILL looking for Dr Leon. Come out, come out, where ever you are! Haha!

Anonymous said...

It contain good health tips yet they are not the one who practice it.
Listening music??Muslims did it,in the other way,listen and read the Quran.
Eat fish without the head??It's already in Quran mention clearly bout how not good it be.
So,just refer the encyclopedia,Quran...

Magic Pumpkin .studio. said...

Refering to imrnze's comment on "good to know there are still critical thinking ppl 'among us'",

The blogger (of BEDTIME STORIES) seems to jump to conclusion that this phrase "among us" is implied to Malay and not Malaysian. I wonder why is that.

With that, you automatically, replied:

"excuse me, but who do you mean by 'among us'? malays? if that's what you're implying, im sorry to say that i am not a malay. and yes, it seems you're implying malays in that context - which is not cool at all.

be a MALAYSIAN, ppl. i beg you."

... now I don't understand why. If imrnze did imply Malaysian, it means that you jumped to conclusion that she meant Malay and not Malaysian which, I think, negates with your last "be a MALAYSIAN"

Do you understand what I'm trying to tell you?

You beg all people to be 1 Malaysia, but the truth is you still see everything it as a compliment for a "Malay" just because you did not see it written as "among Malaysian" and got annoyed because you're not a Malay.

The question is why didn't you see it as "Malaysian" as a possibility in her/his comment?

Also, looking (not judging) from your replies of the comments you received on your blog, you are someone who will not think if the comments have the truth in when someone says something that is different from your point of view.

Yes I know everybody has ego.

Okay, you're a research scientist, something that you really are proud of but you should always think maybe some commenters have professional jobs too.

Yes, there all their comments and opinions but it seems that you did not give the commenters' any room to accept what they're saying.

And the commenters even took trouble too, to give out their opinions but you only respect the comments which lean toward your point of view only.

That's what I think.

Even though this article is not true but you still can take the facts of way of life because they are scientifically proven.

You are scientist too... So, you must know that they are true (the facts on way of life)

Sorry if I hurt you.

Like other commenters, I'm puting my thoughts out to this blog.

Have a nice day~ :)

atreyu strange said...

To the commentor above, I thank you for your GREAT view and input on this topic and the blogger itself.

The apostrophy in imrnze's comment is what caused me to think that way. If he sincerely meant among Malaysia, then why would he want to put the apostrophy? As though the people who come in here to read are aliens?

By the way, I hate the 1Malaysia concept and if you take the time to notice, this article was written way back before the 1Malaysia concept was even uttered by the PM. So please, stop talking about 1Malaysia. I almost choked on my coffee when I read that part! Haha!

You know what's really funny? That you're also making a judgement of the blogger (of BEDTIME STORIES) herself by just this one post! See how ironic it can be? *winks*

Sweet Thinker said...

byk la komen kat cni. benci arr:p

akoo da google. Dr Stephen Carr Leon adalah Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamed.

atreyu strange said...

@ST - LOL. Ko pun sesat kat sini ke?? Haha. Aku yakin betul dgn jawapan ko! Tahniah! Erk!~

v3 said...

whoaa...
yea....

i ever read this b4.

seems lyk hoax.
agreed

Goth80s said...

First of all, there is a Rabbi who's Expert in field of Raising Jewish children. The guy's last name is NOT "Leon" but "Reuben". Placing the name "Leon" instead of "Reuben" could be a SMART HOAX so People will then be curious and then BUY the guy's book because his books are not very popular.

Steven Carr REUBEN is a Rabbi, Doctor Reuben received his Ph.d from Sierra University, he made a research and wrote articles, thesis, and books related to Jewish Life, especially in raising Jewish Children.

To find his thesis : http://search.lasierra.edu/library.html

And these are the books he wrote based on his thesis :

Raising Jewish Children In A Contemporary World : http://www.amazon.com/Raising-Jewish-Children-Contemporary-World/dp/1559583193/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_1

Children of Character : http://www.amazon.com/Children-Character-Leading-Ethical-Everyday/dp/157271011X/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_2

How Will You Raise Your Children : http://www.amazon.com/But-How-Will-Raise-Children/dp/067164369X/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_3

Raising Ethical Children http://www.amazon.com/Raising-Ethical-Children-Steven-Reuben/dp/1559583606

If you are curious, i suggest find the guy's thesis in Library of Sierra University by asking your friends or family who live in USA because it has no digital library.

Goth80s said...

Or.. (of course), you can Buy his Books to compare between the HOAX suspected article with the thoughts in his books :D

Anonymous said...

mudah sahaja..amik yang baik..Sungguh malang bagi tuan sebagai orang yang dipanggil bijak menggunakan internet tapi terlalu bodoh untuk mengambil perkara yang baik dan iktibar..malahan ada yang sengaja menggunakan artikel saudara ini untuk mengatakan merokok itu tidak salah kerana artikel yang tersebar itu satu hoax..tepuk dada tanya selera..(menyokong yahudi yang terang2 musuh islam + ape lagi mendewa2 kan belanda yang pernah menjajah tanah melayu adalah satu kerja BODOH bagi orang yang lupa asal usulnya..melayu=tetap melayu)

atreyu strange said...

ANOTHER ANONYMOUS COMMENT LIKE ABOVE, AND I'M TAKING THIS ARTICLE DOWN BECAUSE APPARENTLY ANONYMOUS ARE PURE IDIOTS WHO CANNOT DIFFERENTIATE SIMPLE THINGS ABOUT LIFESTYLE. LIKE WHY ARE YOU SO STUPID TO EVEN REALIZE MY ARTICLE CLEARLY SAYS THAT THE THINGS SO CALLED BEING 'RESEARCHED' ARE BASIC FUNDAMENTALS ON HOW TO LIVE A HEALTHY LIFESTYLE?? AND WHAT IS IT ABOUT "menyokong yahudi yang terang2 musuh islam" AND ALL?? Why the hell am I being attacked on supporting the Jews?? If someone has taken MY ARTICLE to claim it is PURE HOAX and then supported the Jews, I am at fault?? An ABSOLUTELY ORDINARY BLOGGER LIKE ME? Not a celebrity, not a politician, etc?? Ayeay, you kidding me? Ehh, if you're pissed off at someone else, go rage there okay?

BTW ANONYMOUS, SUCH A COWARD MOVE THERE. Calling people 'bodoh' and all, but WOOTS, look who came in AS AN ANONYMOUS?!! And ohh, "ambil perkara yang baik dan iktibar", okay please do the same to this article I wrote eh?

AND BEFORE LEAVING REMARKS, LEARN A THING OR TWO ABOUT THE AUTHOR OK? BECAUSE I, APPARENTLY, AM NOT A MUSLIM.

I LEAVE THIS SPACE FOR THE GOOD OF YOU PEOPLE TO COMMENT, SO PLEASE HAVE SOME RESPECT ON MY, I REPEAT, MY, PLAYGROUND. If you disagree with me, LEAVE THIS BLOG or if you NEED to comment, learn some respect in your comments. I did not bash any of you for believing Leon's article, so shouldn't you. After all, this is a PERSONAL BLOG, not your daily informative blog.

Ayeay, *rolls eyes*

Anonymous said...

walaupun x sahih tp ak rsa elok jgak crite 2 djdikan pngajaran.. ad some part yg ak rse bleh gna dlm hdup.. yg penting kte lwan zionis.. mnpu utk kbaikan xpe..

Anonymous said...

The article may be a hoax, but apparently the hoax-er has good intentions, after all, he (or she) is only encouraging good values in life. So some of you must accept that others aren't very satisfied since the article has credibility issues, and the other side must acknowledge that some people purely focus on the content, and not the author/credibility. Both have strong points to make. So accept each other's opinion, agree to disagree, and take the good things together :)

Khadijah said...

1. Agree it is a hoax
2. If you have a PhD, your papers won't be difficult to find online. Unfortunately, Stephen Carr Leon does not exist.
3. Even the Malay language is terrible.
4. I don't believe the hoax author has good intentions. He/she is spreading false and possibly harmful information to pass it as credible research. this is very dangerous to society.
5. Did you know that eating certain fish can be harmful for a pregnant woman and developing children because of the mercury content?
6. I am very disappointed to know that they used this as a topic for khutbah. very disappointed. Ramai cendekiawan dan cerdik pandai Muslim, membentangkan tajuk tajuk intelektual dan relevant... Imam pilih nak cakap pasal email yang tak beralas. Malu saya.

Khadijah said...

Kepada saudara Anonymous:

"Melayu = tetap melayu"

tak pernah ada bangsa Melayu sejati. Beratus ratus tahun lamanya kita bangsa Melayu unik kerana kita mengintegrasikan adat, bahasa, tradisi dengan budaya kaum lain.

Tengok sahaja bahasa Melayu. Meja? Itu perkataan Portugis. Orang melayu makan bersila di atas lantai. Rumah kampung orang dulu2 mana ada meja. Meja dan bangku asalan Portugis. Kerusi asalan Arab. Zaman Arab, Cina, India, Portugis telah berlalu.

Kata Hang Tuah: Takkan Melayu hilang di dunia.

Kerana Melayu selesa untuk evolve. Tanpa evolusi, Melayu sudah tentu hilang.

ida_zy said...

salam
sebetulnya saya sedang mencari kesahihan artikel 'dr stephen carr leon'
langsung ketemu blog ini
terima kasih atas pencerahan
sebetulnya saya memang sudah lelah memberitahu teman-teman agar jangan mudah-mudah forward emel tanpa mengenalpasti kesahihannya
tetapi seperti tiada kesan
bukankah dalam Islam sendiri sangat mementingkan kesahihan sesuatu berita
hatta perkara yang baik pun tidak boleh sesuka hati mengatakan itu sabda Nabi, meski isinya baik
wallahua'lam

Anonymous said...

to atreyu strange
u such an ego-maniac person
so proud of urself
that's all i want to say

Lina said...

hahahaha..sama laa.. :D search dr tadi tak jumpa2 kot. lgipun thesis mcm tu ke?? xD pa2 pun ambil yang baik sebagai pedoman, yang tidak jadi panduan.. :D waalahualam

NoktahHitam said...

Ade jugak manusia bodoh.. Kesian you, as much as I'd like to believe it's true, in my opinion, this is nothing more that a utopia. The author is living in his dream. I had a few jew friends when I was abroad, non ever mentioned about this.

Anyway, just let them yap about it. These fuck up busters are just typical. Ambil yg cetek, jangan yg dalam, kerana dalam itu susah.

Maher said...

sebenarnya saya tak kisah kalau saudara hendak mengatakan org yang menyebarkan artikel di atas sebagai an average joe atau org lain yg menyebarkan kepada rakan-rakan sebagai spammer, tapi saya mencadangkan agar saudara lebih menumpukan hujah saudara kepada kesahihan maklumat-maklumat yang terkandung di dalamnya samada betul ataupun tidak.

Kalau isinya betul, pada saya la saya kisah apa kalau ada kesalahan grammar ke, Dr. Stephen Carr Leon tu wujud ke tak....saya atak kisah. Sekalipun yg tulis artikel ni menggunakan nama "Makcik Kutip Sampah" pun kalau terbukti benar saya akan hargainya. Saya tak kata artikel di atas benar, tapi buktikannya dengan menerangkan motif penulis ke, kepalsuan fakta ke...

saya cadangkan saudara kaji artikel seorang penulis yg membangkang aorg menganggap hitler pembela org islam.

http://obefiend.blogspot.com/2010/07/adolph-hitler-and-muslim-revisionist.html

atreyu strange said...

@Maher - things like eat more fish, don't smoke, etc, aren't they things we already know by now? research done over and over again? that's why i keep repeating the fact that these are BASIC LIFESTYLES that we already know. the difference is whether we practice them or not. and that's also why i cannot agree that this email is circulating. everyone is taking it as though it's some new findings by this unknown man when it is clearly not.

obe? i'm a big fan of that guy! he's a living troll! LOL

dong_sanchai said...

hi,jumpa blog ni sbb cr dr stephen leon tu.
sokong awk,rasa artikel ni hoax, tp tensen la tgk org sibuk share kat FB. sibuk nk promote yahudi lifestyle.lgpun mmg kebanyaakan point lifestyle tu mmg kite da tahu based on byk research yg lebih reliable. pastu boleh pulak anynomous ni nk marah2 pulak bila artikel ni di persoalkan. pelik2la.
btw, baru notice post ni since feb 2009. thumbs up to u blogger

asma' said...

I just received the mail and was really intrigued to find this so called thesis so I can learn a thing or two.

and yup, I cannot find it either :)

asma' said...

plus, all those good diet, children upbringing and more can be found if we study the sunnah of our prophet Muhammad s.a.w. first- before scrambling to look at the other side.

Monkey D Luffy said...

Hi, I'm posting just to share my opinions on this so called thesis.

First, I doubt that the translator is a Malaysian, why? Because you can find some words that are rare in Malay Language writing such as:
metamatik
korma
taboo
sang ibu
musik
violin
semuga

and maybe some more in the article.

Second, a thesis for PhD which took 8 years, and only this short?

Third, I red another version of this article in FB, and there are some addition to it, about cigarette price in other country, the law, bla bla... emm I smell something fishy here hehe..

adios...

buk said...

oooooooooooooooooo yessss..........back to the sunnah of Nabi Muhammad saw

nuur said...

the article has some good points but the facts about Jews there not nececessarily to be true , at least for the person who claimed that she/he translated to article from some website.

Maher said...

i dunno...maybe the translator is a malaysian...coz u see, earlier we use bilek instead of bilik...and other examples...so maybe the words u pointed out comes from classical malay...yeah who knows?


@atreyu : oh u like obe? yeah he's good..oh no, he is damn good, i love it when he tells his story with his roomates...but now i seldom read his articles...maybe the genres are different now.

Naim Zin said...

yes! another rational malaysian! thank you for giving me hope!

Anonymous said...

i have found the english version! =)

ambil iktibar, jgn cpat melenting k!
dorang just practise apa yg kita xpractise...
bnda ni klu di kaji, mmg btol, such as ikan baik utk otak, kekacang, latihan math and so on...yes, they are good because they are practising the healthy lifestyle and practising things dat make their generations even more clever than any other generation...apa salah klu kita contohi dorg dari segi makan ikan, kekcang n wat latihan math, islam xlarang pun...ISLAM IS GLOBAL, kita bole contohi merka selagi ia xbertentangan dgn agama, i mean mengambil positif apa yg baik dr mereka, sepertimana mereka mengamalkan cara pemakanan yg dituntut dalam Islam dan sbginya...

the article is in dis site: http://shahidpages.wordpress.com/2009/03/31/why-jews-are-intelligent/

Post a Comment

Hi Anonymous, you are such a coward! Please, I beg you, FLAME me!

  © 2008-2009 'Morning Drink' template by ourblogtemplates.com. Edited by atreyu strange.

Back to TOP